The Washington Post's Richard Cohen and just about everyone who attended the White House Correspondents' Dinner thinks Stephen Colbert's attack on Bush and the press corps was not funny. NPR's political junkie, Ken Rudin, said yesterday that Colbert bombed with the crowd -- but the rest of the world loved him -- much like Jon Stewart's performance at the Oscars.
Cohen begrudingly admits this fact, saying that Colbert has defenders "all over the blogosphere." He also seems a little hurt when he points out that Colbert "took a shot at the news corps for purportedly being nothing more than stenographers recording what the Bush White House said."
He adds: "But he was, like much of the blogosphere itself, telling like-minded people what they already know and alienating all the others."
He's obviously missing the point. The reason noone in the Bush administration or the White House press corps liked Colbert's jokes is that they were the butt of them. And the reason that the rest of the public loved the performance is that we're the ones who are too often alienated by those in power and in the Beltway press.
Greg Mitchell writes on MediaCulture that "the same media that's trashing Stephen Colbert gave a pass to Bush's jokes about missing WMDs in Iraq two years earlier."
He writes, "Still, with the knocks on Colbert increasing, I have to ask: Where was the outrage when President Bush made fun of not finding those pesky WMDs at a very similar media dinner -- in the same ballroom -- two years ago? It represents a shameful episode for the American media, and presidency, yet is rarely mentioned today."
The problem is not that Colbert wasn't funny. The problem was that his jokes were right on target, and nobody in the room could take it.
One of the best defenses of Colbert came from Stewart himself. An E & P article recounts it:
"It was balls-alicious," Stewart said. "Apparently he was under the impression that they'd hired him to do what he does every night on television -- that is, make fun of conservatives, public officials, and the press in the guise of an O'Reillyesque talk show host....We've never been prouder of him, but HOLY ----."
We need more people like Colbert and the bloggers supporting him not just to hold Bush accountable but also to hold the press accountable when they fail us, as they have done recently by putting off publishing the domestic spying story and too easily accepting the administration's line on WMD's.