The title of Andrew Dominik's "The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford" says a lot about the movie itself. You know what to expect and, just like its title, the film is drawn out – to the tune of 160 minutes. The fact that the film's title wasn't shortened from the title of Ron Hansen's novel (from which it was adapted), though, says the most about "The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford."
Dominik could have taken this story Hollywood and slapped a snazzy title on it to make it more marketable. Instead, Dominik, the film's producers (Warner Bros. and Plan B Entertainment), cinematographer Roger Deakins, and cast focus their efforts on turning this modern Western into a work of art.
Ironically, Dominik and Deakins put the "Mid" in this Western by shooting, not in Missouri or Colorado, but in Alberta and Winnipeg, Canada. The result is one breathtaking backdrop after another.
The film begins with Jesse, played by Brad Pitt, standing all by his lonesome, taking in the beauty of an open wheat field along with the viewer as a voiceover narration gives a detailed description of Jesse (which, I presume, is directly from Hansen's novel). These opening minutes set the tone for the film, stating simply that Pitt and imagery will keep the viewer engaged.
But what would Jesse James be without his band of outlaws?
The story begins with Jesse camped out in the woody hills of Missouri with his brother Frank, played by Sam Shepard, and his fellow train robbers. Here, Robert Ford, played by Casey Affleck, makes an awkward attempt at coaxing Frank into letting him become a permanent member of the James gang, while his brother Charley Ford, played by Sam Rockwell, effortlessly fits in with the rough crew.
The train the gang is waiting to rob approaches in pitch black, allowing Deakins to work his magic. As the light from the train's headlight passes through the forest, the robbers' masked faces emerge hauntingly from the darkness.
When Jesse finds the train's safe essentially empty, he exhibits the short temper that made him a notorious killer, his eyes penetrating any who cross him. But the robbery sets into motion a chain of events that lead to Jesse's demise. From there, the list of men Jesse trusts dwindles down to the Ford brothers.
From there, as the scenery changes from fall to winter to spring, Dominik and Deakins continue to experiment, shooting from behind 19th-century-style window panes, distorting the figures beyond – perhaps as a way of showing how all men and their intentions can become distorted in the West.
One of the best scenes of the film comes during Jesse's journey to test his partners' integrity and he stops by the unkempt home of gang member Ed Miller, played by Garret Dillahunt. Ed, who is noticeably slow in the head, is overwhelmed by Jesse's imposing presence and is barely able to speak. But Pitt doesn't steal the scene. Instead, his domineering persona is matched by Dillahunt's timidity and mumbled words. To the film's credit, it trades flawless annunciation by its actors for more fractured and realistic dialogue, befitting of uneducated characters.
The rest of the film's memorable scenes involve Pitt, Affleck and Rockwell. Rather than owning the screen, Pitt seems to bring the best out of his supporting actors as Affleck delivers a breakout performance and Rockwell plays his character into a more central role than he might have otherwise been.
An admirer of Jesse from childhood, Robert is driven by his desire to be as famous as the outlaw. His grand plan is to become Jesse's partner and go from there, but when he is shunned by his idol, his plan changes. Through Affleck, the viewer sees the fine line between Robert's love and hate for Jesse, framed in an uncomfortable boy trying to become a man in the West.
For Charley, Rockwell brings back a toned down version of his "Wild Bill" Wharton character from "The Green Mile." Charley contrasts his brother as the type of sidekick Jesse is looking for: Good-natured, easy to talk to, and too simple to be disloyal.
As for Pitt, he again proves there's no role he can't play. Much like his characters in "Babel" and "Snatch," Pitt allows himself to be a little rough around the edges. While he does have one nude scene, it isn't for the sake of female viewers. In one of Jesse's early encounters with Robert, he's seen bathing (with the camera at his back) to show the scars he's received as an outlaw. Not only scars from bullet wounds, but the emotional scars of having to carry a gun with him at all times – even in the bathtub.
In Jesse's last days, Pitt's acting genius comes to the forefront as he teeters from one emotional extreme to another as evidence of how paranoia has consumed Jesse's life, even at home. At times he's generous to his friends and affectionate with his family. Other times he's anxious and even unleashes the same maniacal laughter he perfected in "Fight Club." To his family, Jesse is Thomas Howard, a loving husband and father. He's gone out of his way to isolate them from his violent, murderous lifestyle, but when he takes in the Ford brothers, they are ultimately exposed to the gruesome nature of his secret life.
The film's greatest failure and triumph come on the day Jesse is assassinated.
That morning Robert goes to the water pump to calm his nerves. Perhaps trying to illustrate the adrenaline rush Robert is feeling, Dominik unnecessarily intensifies the effect of the water rushing from the pump and the wind sweeping through the tall grass around him. This visual experiment detracts from the tension of the moment.
But minutes later Dominik redeems himself with an incredible portrayal of Jesse's murder. His death isn't slow and dramatic. Rather, it's instantaneous and, because of the authority Pitt gives the role, epic. The most striking aspect of Jesse's death is how dull and vacant his once-pulsating eyes are as he lies on the floor bleeding in his wife's arms.
The credits don't roll there, though, for the fate of the Ford brothers have yet to be presented. Throughout the final sequence, Dominik tries some freeze frames to transition from one scene to the next, reminiscent of "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid."
While the film lacks a "Butch Cassidy" ending to ensure itself a place among classic Westerns and despite its length, this visual masterpiece, driven by Pitt and Affleck's performances, is a can't-miss Western. The bigger the screen - or, in this case, canvas - the better.