Whatever happened to my Rock and Roll?
Does anyone out there have the number for a good attorney?
I want to file a class action lawsuit against The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame for false advertising.
I just saw the list of 2008 inductees, which completely shatters the Sha-Na-Na theory that, "Rock and Roll is here to stay, it will never die." (Great, now I've got that song stuck in my head...)
The list includes such "rock" stalwarts as professional exhibitionist turned D-list actress Madonna and long-forgotten disco diva Donna Summer.
Of course, it also includes well-deserving artists: Leonard Cohen, John Mellencamp, The Beastie Boys, The Dave Clark Five, hip-hop pioneer Afrika Bambaataa, and instrumentalists The Ventures.
Talk about a schizophrenic class!
The Hall nominating committee, made up of Rolling Stone magazine mafioso Jann Wenner and his hand-picked cabal of rock writers, has made a tremendous error in judgment to think that Madonna--whose contributions to rock are about as notable as Lawrence Welk's, or Donna Summer, who, at the height of her career represented the very antithesis of simple, hit-you-in-the-gut Rock and Roll--were ever as influential to the genre as other non-rock greats, like legendary blues musician Muddy Waters or jazz genius Miles Davis.
I understand that the Hall pays tribute to the artists in other genres who profoundly influence rock music. After all, rock has always been an amalgam of various styles and cultures--rockabilly, pop, blues, country, jazz, and more recently hip-hop, among others. My problem is not with honoring other styles, but with honoring Madonna and Donna in particular.
What has Madonna's big contribution been to rock music? She's influenced pop music, no doubt, but can anyone name an actual rock song that she wrote (or even performed) that changed the way subsequent rockers approached the craft? As for Summer, anyone who was around during the late '70s/early '80s (in other words, none of my fellow classmates--except Old Man Ryan) remembers that disco was the sworn enemy of rock. Thousands of rock fans attended rallies in baseball stadiums and cheered on the bulldozing of disco records beneath banners that screamed: DISCO SUCKS!
So to have Summer inducted into the Hall of Fame is pretty much akin to stepping into a time machine set for 2025, and discovering that Osama Bin Laden's head has been added to Mount Rushmore!
Madonna's lasting legacy, meanwhile, has been serving as a mentor for some of pop music's worst performers (i.e. literally engaging Britney in the Kiss of Death).
The bottom line is that the Rock Hall of Fame is a complete joke.
Any institution claiming to honor the genre while inducting these two before Iggy Pop and the Stooges, The MC-5, or even commercially-obscure (but musically influential) bands like Sonic Youth or Television, among countless others, shouldn't be taken seriously.
But--like everything else--I DO take it seriously. I know, it's only Rock and Roll...but gosh darn it, I like it, I like it, yes I do!
Why? Probably because I spent my 20s as a semi-professional musician, and I owe my life to Bob Dylan, John Lennon, The Band, Van Morrison, Sonic Youth...ROCK AND ROLL, BABY!
However, I am glad to see that songwriter Leonard Cohen is getting his due (He's my man!). True, he wasn't a rocker either, but anyone who follows rock songwriting knows he has been a major influence on any number of rock artists, from Elvis Costello to U2 to REM to Nick Cave to Jeff Buckley--basically anyone who gives a damn about their lyrics. Right up there with Bob Dylan, Cohen has written some of the most poetic lyrics ever to accompany music. I mean, anyone who can come up with this deserves to be in every Hall of Fame ever created:
Ah, you hate to see another tired man lay down his hand
like he had given the holy game of poker.
And while he talks his dreams to sleep
you notice there's a highway that's curling up
like smoke above his shoulder.
It's curling just like smoke above his shoulder...
So, to think the woman who told us she felt like a virgin while gyrating through the Venetian canals and the disco diva whose main contribution is a looped orgasm, are now in the same boat as Leonard Cohen tells me that...as Mr. Cohen would say:
Everybody knows that the boat is leaking
Everybody knows that the captain lied
Everybody got that sinking feeling
Like their father or their dog just died...
Oh well, at least The Ventures and the Dave Clark Five got some long overdue recognition.
My only hope is that the Beastie Boys will stay true to their form and make a complete mockery of the ceremony (after Mr. Cohen has been inducted)...
Just please tell me that this doesn't mean we'll be seeing the Spice Girls inducted anytime soon (honestly, I'm all ziga-zigged out for one lifetime)!